A study by scientists at the National Museum of Natural History (MNHN), funded by Ademe (the French environment and energy management agency) and published in the Journal of Applied Ecology, shows that temporarily shutting down wind turbines at night, during peak bat activity periods, can cut their mortality fivefold. The finding is reigniting the debate over the coexistence of wind energy and biodiversity.
A heavy toll on France's bats
France is now home to more than 10,000 wind turbines, spread across roughly 600 wind farms. Each year, these installations kill about 60,000 bats, either struck directly by the blades or killed by barotrauma caused by the sudden drop in air pressure the blades generate. Bats are active only at night, and their activity rises sharply when winds are light and temperatures mild — conditions that also happen to be when turbines keep spinning without necessarily generating much electricity.
Curtailment, a solution already partly in place
The technique studied, known as curtailment, involves stopping or slowing the blades during the time windows when the risk of collision is highest. It is already applied at just under half of France's wind farms. According to the MNHN scientists, optimized curtailment — one that factors in not only wind speed but also temperature and rainfall — could prevent the deaths of nearly 48,000 bats a year.
What's the cost to electricity production?
Curtailment comes with an energy cost. In its simplest form, it results in an estimated production loss of 10% to 15%. But by fine-tuning the parameters that trigger the shutdown, that loss can be cut to just 3% to 5%, with almost the same level of protection for bats. It's a trade-off that wind farm operators will increasingly have to factor in, as onshore wind power continues to expand in France. Some regions are also stepping up on species protection, like Marseille, crowned France's biodiversity capital this year.
This issue is part of a broader challenge around protecting natural habitats, documented in a recent official report on biodiversity decline in France. It also illustrates the trade-offs the energy transition requires, even as the global trajectory of climate warming keeps worsening.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are bats especially exposed to wind turbines?
They hunt at night in flight, often at blade height, and are drawn to the insects that gather around the turbine masts. They can be killed by a direct impact or by barotrauma, an internal injury caused by the sudden change in air pressure near the moving blades.
Is curtailment mandatory in France?
It isn't applied systematically: it's in place at just under 50% of France's wind farms, usually imposed by environmental authorities on a case-by-case basis during project review.
Does curtailment also affect birds?
The MNHN study focuses specifically on bats, whose nighttime activity peaks differ from those of birds, which are studied more through other tools such as radar detection or shutdowns during migration periods.
Sources
- National Museum of Natural History — How to reduce bat mortality in wind farms
- Actu-Environnement — Adapted nighttime wind turbine shutdowns cut bat mortality by more than 80%
- La Relève et La Peste — Stopping wind turbines at night could save 48,000 bats a year
This article was written with the help of artificial intelligence. Editorial policy













