Updated: October 19, 2026. Two studies published this week tell what looks like a contradictory story: on one hand, secondhand shopping is declining in France, according to the Sustainable Retail Barometer from consulting firm BearingPoint; on the other, Vinted has just entered the Top 5 most-visited sites in the country, according to second-quarter 2026 audience figures published by the Fevad (France's e-commerce federation). How do the two coexist?
What the BearingPoint Study Shows
According to the 2026 Sustainable Retail Barometer, only 29% of French consumers say they bought a secondhand product from a professional seller over the past year, compared with a European average of 36%. For peer-to-peer resale, the gap holds steady: 33% of French consumers use it, versus 38% in Europe. The fashion sector, long the historic engine of secondhand shopping, shows a similar decline: 29% through professionals, 31% peer-to-peer. The study also points to a lack of trust: only 53% of French consumers believe in brands' sustainability commitments, compared with 66% across Europe, and barely 28% are willing to pay a premium of more than 10% for a responsible product.
Yet Vinted Is Climbing the Audience Rankings
At the same time, second-quarter 2026 audience data compiled by the Fevad show that Vinted has surpassed 20 million monthly unique visitors and now ranks among the five most-visited sites in France, behind giants like Amazon and Leboncoin. The platform dominates in particular the secondhand clothing segment, where Leboncoin remains unbeatable for product diversity.
How to Read This Paradox
The two studies don't measure the same thing. BearingPoint surveys the proportion of French consumers who bought secondhand over the year, a penetration figure that is declining. The Fevad, meanwhile, measures the volume of visits to a given site, regardless of the number of distinct buyers. One plausible explanation: a user base already converted to secondhand shopping is coming back more often, while new buyers aren't joining the movement at the same pace as before. In other words, secondhand shopping may be concentrating around regulars rather than continuing to win over new customers, a phenomenon already observed in our article on the growing place of secondhand shopping in French consumers' habits.
A Backdrop of Strained Purchasing Power
This slowdown comes as confidence in purchasing power remains fragile in France, as shown by the latest economic indicators detailed in our article on how brick-and-mortar stores are holding up against the purchasing-power crisis. Budget caution is pushing some households to buy less, not necessarily to buy differently. The success of formats like social commerce, analyzed in our feature on how TikTok Shop and Instagram are reshaping French consumers' shopping habits, also illustrates another shift in consumption, one geared more toward impulse buying than toward responsible secondhand shopping.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Secondhand Shopping Really Declining in France?
Yes, in terms of the proportion of French buyers: 29%, compared with a European average of 36%, according to BearingPoint's 2026 Sustainable Retail Barometer.
Why Is Vinted Growing While the Sector Declines?
Because the two figures measure different things: one tracks the number of French buyers, the other the volume of visits to a specific site, driven by already-converted users who return more often.
What Is the Main Obstacle to Buying Secondhand in France?
The lack of trust in brands' sustainability commitments (only 53%) and the low willingness to pay more for a responsible product (just 28% accept a premium of more than 10%).
Sources
- Ecommercemag.fr — The French secondhand market loses momentum
- HR Associés — Analysis of the Fevad Q2 2026 barometer
This article was written with the help of artificial intelligence. Editorial policy













